Despite the stigma surrounding made-for-TV movies, many have become hidden gems. These films often tell gripping stories based on real-life events, especially shocking murders. Here are ten notable TV movies from the 1990s that were inspired by actual murder cases.
10. Deadly Whispers (1995)
Starring Tony Danza, this film recounts the tragic murder of 19-year-old Kathy Bonney by her father, Thomas Lee Bonney, in Camden County, North Carolina. After a heated argument over her boyfriend, Thomas shot Kathy 27 times. He claimed insanity due to a supposed multiple personality disorder but was sentenced to life in prison. As of 2024, he remains incarcerated in a minimum-security facility.
9. What Happened to Bobby Earl? (1997)
Also known as Murder in a College Town, this film stars Kate Jackson as Rose Pratt, based on the real-life murder of her son, Roger “Butch” Pratt. After joining a fraternity, Butch was kidnapped and killed by his friend Eddy Swiger, who feared Butch would expose his criminal activities. Swiger and four others were convicted, with Swiger still serving his life sentence as of 2024.
8. Cries Unheard: The Donna Yaklich Story (1994)
Jaclyn Smith stars as Donna Yaklich, who hired two teens to kill her allegedly abusive husband, Detective Dennis Yaklich. After the murder, Donna cashed in a life insurance policy. She received a 40-year sentence but was released in 2006. The film explores themes of abuse and betrayal.
7. Death in Small Doses (1995)
This movie is based on the murder of Nancy Lyon, who died from arsenic poisoning. Her husband, Richard Lyon, was convicted after a series of suspicious illnesses she suffered during their relationship. Richard is currently serving a life sentence and has maintained his innocence.
6. Beauty’s Revenge (1991)
Featuring Tracey Gold, this film illustrates the jealousy-driven murder of 21-year-old Lisa Cihaski by her friend Lori Esker. The two had a tumultuous friendship exacerbated by their romantic involvement with the same man. Lori was sentenced for first-degree intentional homicide and was released in 2019.
5. A Killer Among Friends (1992)
Tiffani Thiessen portrays Jennifer Monroe, inspired by the real-life murder of Michele “Missy” Avila. Michele’s friends drowned her in a forest after a heated argument. The killers were not apprehended until three years later and received lengthy prison sentences, but both have since been paroled.
4. Deadly Medicine (1991)
Based on the crimes of nurse Genene Jones, this film portrays her suspected role in the deaths of numerous infants. She was convicted of one murder and sentenced to 99 years, but the case was reopened in 2020, leading to a life sentence for another murder. Genene is currently in prison.
3. Lies of the Heart: The Laurie Kellogg Story (1994)
Jenny Garth stars as Laurie Kellogg, who was convicted of second-degree murder for the death of her husband, Malcolm “Bruce” Kellogg. The film explores the complex dynamics involving Laurie, her teenage lover, and the events leading to the murder. Laurie was released from prison in 2019.
2. No One Would Tell (1996)
Candace Cameron Bure plays a character based on the real-life murder of Amy Carnevale. The film depicts the brutal relationship between Amy and her boyfriend, Jamie Fuller, who ultimately killed her in a jealous rage. Jamie is currently serving a life sentence.
1. Black Widow Murders: The Blanche Taylor Moore Story (1993)
Elizabeth Montgomery portrays Blanche Taylor Moore, who was convicted of murdering her boyfriend by poisoning him with arsenic. Suspected in several other deaths, Moore's story highlights the chilling nature of her crimes. She remains on death row as of 2024.
These films not only offer captivating stories but also serve as reminders of the real-life tragedies that inspired them, showcasing the darker side of human nature.